RAPAPORT… Two pieces of green glass imitating valuable tourmalines have turned up at the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) after manufacturers apparently used innovative techniques to make the shards look like real gemstones.
The bluish-green prisms weighing 1.91 and 1.92 carats resembled either Paraiba tourmaline with copper inclusions or emeralds with pyrite inclusions, the GIA said in a recent journal article.
The refractive index of 1.50 indicated the pieces were not tourmaline. Furthermore, microscopic examination at the GIA laboratory in Carlsbad, California — which had received them for its identification service — showed that each prism comprised two different types of man-made glass fused together. Further testing revealed the presence of copper, which the makers had added as platelets to imitate genuine inclusions.
Paraiba tourmaline is one of the priciest varieties of the gemstone, noted senior staff gemologists Amy Cooper and Heidi Breitzmann and staff gemologist Jamie Price in the Winter 2020 edition of Gems & Gemology, the GIA’s quarterly academic journal.
“The polish lines seen on the surfaces of both glasses clearly indicate that these were faceted to resemble a natural rough stone, and the trigonal outline and elongate shape suggest the goal was to imitate tourmaline, which has a similar appearance,” they explained. “The copper inclusions and neon bluish green color would further indicate that the manufacturer intended to imitate Paraiba-type tourmaline.”
Coincidentally, while the Carlsbad lab was examining the pieces, a natural Brazilian tourmaline also came in for the GIA’s identification and origin service. The stone had the same copper inclusions that the fakes had attempted to mimic, Cooper, Breitzmann and Price pointed out.
“It is unusual to see man-made glass cut to imitate a natural rough crystal with eye-visible inclusions,” they continued. “These pieces…were certainly interesting from a gemological perspective to demonstrate the variety of creative ways imitation gems are produced.”
Image: The green glass manufacturers had made to imitate tourmaline. (Diego Sanchez/GIA)
Manufacturers Use Green Glass to Mimic Tourmaline
The Bottom Line
- Two green glass pieces weighing about 1.9 carats each were identified by the GIA as man-made glass fused from two types of glass with added copper platelets to mimic natural inclusions.
- The glass imitations resembled Paraiba tourmaline or emeralds with pyrite inclusions but had a refractive index inconsistent with natural tourmaline.
- The GIA noted the unusual practice of cutting man-made glass to imitate natural rough crystals with visible inclusions, highlighting the creativity in producing imitation gems.
More Stories
AGTA Elects New Board Members
The four incoming directors will start their term in February 2027.
Signet Sales Slide in Second Quarter
Revenue down 0.5% year on year to $1.53 billion for the period.
Phillips Names New Jewelry Specialist in Italy
Gaia Maffioli brings 15 years of experience to the role.
