RAPAPORT… Costco Wholesale and Tiffany & Co. have finally laid to rest an eight-year legal dispute over alleged trademark infringement and counterfeiting.
“The parties have amicably resolved their dispute,” Costco’s attorney, David Bernstein, told Rapaport News Tuesday. Bernstein declined to provide any further details of the settlement, which was dismissed with prejudice July 19. That means the case is settled permanently and cannot be brought back to court. A spokesperson for Tiffany chose not to comment, as did the jeweler’s lawyer, Brendan O’Rourke.
Tiffany first filed suit against Costco in February 2013, claiming the wholesaler’s use of the word “Tiffany” on its engagement-ring display misled consumers into believing the rings were made by Tiffany & Co. In 2015, the court sided with Tiffany, handing down a $21 million judgment.
However, an appeals court overturned that decision in 2020, ruling that “reasonable” customers would realize Costco was describing the rings’ setting and was not selling them as Tiffany engagement rings. The case was set to return to court shortly to be decided by a jury.
Image: Tiffany & Co. engagement rings. (Shutterstock)
Tiffany, Costco Settle Long-Running Dispute
The Bottom Line
- Costco and Tiffany & Co. settled their trademark dispute, with the case dismissed with prejudice on July 19.
- The lawsuit began in 2013, with Tiffany alleging Costco misled consumers by using the 'Tiffany' name on engagement ring displays.
- A $21 million judgment in favor of Tiffany was overturned on appeal in 2020, with the court ruling consumers would not be confused.
More Stories
Star Diamond Names New CEO
Jean Raymond Boulle II will succeed Lester Kemp, who served as interim chief.
Plumb Club and JVC to Collaborate on Advocacy, Ethical Practices
New partnership aims to strengthen jewelry sector.
Christie’s Puts $12M Price Tag on Pink Diamond
Auction house will also offer Cartier ruby brooch for $7.7 million at Hong Kong sale.
