Sotheby’s Sale Disappoints as Top Items Go Unsold 

The top four lots offered at the most recent Sotheby’s Hong Kong jewelry sale failed to find buyers, with the total auction generating only HKD 86.2 million ($11.1 million). 

A necklace composed of 108 jadeite beads and a clasp set with a cabochon ruby and brilliant-cut diamonds, estimated at HKD 50 million ($6.4 million), was set to headline the October 2 Magnificent Jewels sale in Hong Kong. However, that item, along with the second highlight, a ring with a round brilliant-cut, 67.20-carat, fancy-vivid-yellow, VVS2-clarity diamond center stone expected to fetch HKD 39 million ($5 million), were both withdrawn by their consignors, Sotheby’s said last week. 

Meanwhile, a rivière necklace with 71 graduating emerald-cut, D-color, internally flawless and flawless diamonds weighing a total of 114.92 carats, and carrying a high price of HKD 30 million ($2.6 million), also went unsold. The same is true for the fourth item in the presale top 10: a ring featuring a step-cut, 22.83-carat Colombian emerald flanked by two trapeze-shaped diamonds, which was set to bring in as much as HKD 16.5 million ($2.1 million).  

“While we didn’t get to see [those lots] sell in the room this season, they were both exceptional pieces in every sense, and attracted significant interest prior to the sale,” Sotheby’s told Rapaport News. “We are confident they will find a new home very soon.”

Here are the top 10 lots purchased at the auction: 

Cushion-shaped Kashmir sapphire set between two half-moon-shaped diamonds ring image
A ring with a cushion-shaped, 12.52-carat Kashmir sapphire, set between two half-moon-shaped diamonds, realized HKD 7.2 million ($926,280), within its estimated range. 
Colombian emerald with a surround of brilliant-cut diamonds ring image
This ring, with a step-cut, 14.93-carat Colombian emerald with a surround of brilliant-cut diamonds, brought in HKD 5.5 million ($710,148), just above its lower presale price. 
Cushion-shaped fancy-vivid-yellow diamond ring image
Sotheby’s sold this ring, containing a cushion-shaped, 16.36-carat, fancy-vivid-yellow, VS1-clarity diamond, for HKD 5 million ($648,396). That price met with presale expectations. 
Pear-shaped diamond ring image
A ring with a pear-shaped, 10.19-carat, very-light-pink, SI1-clarity diamond went for HKD 3.4 million ($432,264), beating its HKD 3.2 million ($412,027) high price. 
Cushion-shaped Burmese sapphire surrounded by brilliant-cut diamonds ring image
Another ring, this one bearing a cushion-shaped, 12.34-carat Burmese sapphire surrounded by brilliant-cut diamonds, more than doubled its upper estimate to fetch HKD 3.2 million ($416,826). 
Van Cleef & Arpels Zip necklace, covered in brilliant-cut diamonds, image
This Van Cleef & Arpels Zip necklace, covered in brilliant-cut diamonds, garnered HKD 3.2 million ($416,826), well over its HKD 2 million ($257,517) presale high price. 
Oval and cushion-shaped Burmese ruby clusters, surrounded by brilliant-cut and pear-shaped diamonds image
A necklace designed as a series of oval and cushion-shaped Burmese ruby clusters, surrounded by brilliant-cut and pear-shaped diamonds, raked in HKD 3.1 million ($401,388), within estimates. 
Pair of earrings suspending pear-shaped diamonds image
A pair of earrings, one suspending a pear-shaped, 7.19-carat, H-color, VVS2-clarity diamond, and the second a pear-shaped, 7.07-carat, H-color, VS2-clarity diamond, sold for HKD 2.6 million ($339,636), surpassing its HKD 2 million ($257,517) upper estimate. 
Heart-shaped Burmese ruby and diamonds by Harry Winston image
Harry Winston created this ring, set with a heart-shaped Burmese ruby and diamonds. The piece exceeded its HKD 1.4 million ($180,262) high price, achieving HKD 2.6 million ($331,917). 
Cushion-shaped ruby and a round-cornered square diamond ring by Cartier image
A toi et moi ring by Cartier, featuring a cushion-shaped, 8.18-carat ruby and a round-cornered square, 5.03-carat, G-color, VVS1-clarity diamond, also smashed its HKD 1.5 million ($193,138) upper presale estimate to go for HKD 2.3 million ($293,322) 

Main images: The top four items that did not sell at the auction. (Sotheby’s)

Stay up to date by signing up for our diamond and jewelry industry news and analysis.

Sotheby’s Sale Disappoints as Top Items Go Unsold 

Top Stories from Rapaport

Featured