Many analysts are forecasting a less-than-average holiday shopping season due to a sharp drop in consumer confidence over the past few months. “When we asked consumers if they planned to spend more or less this season than they did last year, around 20 percent said more, while 80 percent said less,” observed Britt Beemer, chairman and chief executive officer (CEO) of America’s Research Group, based in Charleston, South Carolina. “The consumer is scared of what is going on,” agreed Dion. “And we are seeing that they have already started to pull back on their spending.”
Retailers Optimistic
Not all, however, are feeling pessimistic about this upcoming holiday season. “Throughout the retail community, I think the retailers and retail associations are actually forecasting a good holiday shopping season,” said Ray Florio, senior executive of Chicago-based global management consultancy firm Accenture.
The reasoning behind retailers’ optimism, Florio added, was that “In September, things have been pretty stable, as there was a good performance in the back-to-school shopping sales.” He is personally skeptical, however, that this will translate into a strong holiday season. “I am a bit hesitant to buy into that because there is a large amount of uncertainty out there right now.”
Discounting and Deals
Analysts predict retailers will most likely offer a large number of discounts and deals on their merchandise to attract frugal consumers hard-hit by the tepid economy. “Retailers should understand that the customer is looking for deals, value and bargains. They are looking to stretch their dollars,” advised Dion. How far retailers can stretch their deals, added Beemer, will play a pivotal role in just how successful the holiday season will be. “If they want a big Christmas, they can make one, and if they want a smaller one, they can make that, too.”
One certainty this December is that brick-and-mortar retailers will face pressure to discount from online vendors and educated shoppers. “You can expect many more consumers to be walking through the aisles with their smart phones, scanning barcodes and looking around for who has the lowest price, or ordering online this season,” said Florio. “Things are not going to be business as usual — the information age has really taken over, with bad and good effects.”
Discounting to attract customers, however, may be a double-edged sword. While low prices inevitably help merchandise sell, they also cheapen its perceived value. “Retailers who give into discounting need to have a more long-term focus. Because in the end, it may damage the brand — especially in the high end, where you don’t want to be associated with other value brands out there,” warned Florio.
Will Luxury Hold?
Though most analysts expect luxury retailers to be more resilient in a difficult holiday season, many still are worried that current economic conditions could prove too much of a burden for the luxury sector to bear. “Luxury retail has been ‘okay’ so far, but if the stock market continues to be bumpy, it will impact a lot of affluent consumer spending — affluent consumers are very sensitive to the market,” noted Florio.
Erratic price increases for items like jewelry and diamonds could further dampen luxury spending this season. “Two of the things that affect jewelry and diamond demand are the volatility and the price. And we are seeing that both these factors are high, so that is likely to hold back consumers or reduce demand for jewelry, diamonds and other metals,” said Rohit Savant, senior commodity analyst at New York–based research and consulting firm CPM Group.
Caution Ahead
Analysts are warning retailers to tread lightly this December and prepare for scenarios that will likely be worse than expected. “If I were a retailer, I would really watch my purchases, watch what I bought and try to not overbuy,” said Dion.
“Things are looking good right now,” added Florio. “It’s the same way you advise anybody who is saving and budgeting — you hope for the best, but prepare for the worst. And this is especially the case now, with all the uncertainty that is out there.“



