The people and companies on the list, which was provided by French tax authorities, allegedly deposited funds totaling nearly $1 billion in the Swiss subsidiary of HSBC Bank in an attempt to evade taxes.
The fraud case dates back to January 2009, when the French home of Hervé Falciani was searched by the Nice police at the request of the Swiss authorities. Falciani was suspected of stealing confidential information from his former employer, the HSBC Swiss subsidiary. In the search, a compact disc was retrieved that reportedly contained data on 127,000 bank transactions for 79,000 clients from around the globe for fiscal years 2006 and 2007.
The French tax authorities retained the records on French citizens for their own investigation and forwarded the names of other bank clients to the tax authorities in several other countries.
Where’s the Evidence?
In January 2011, the BBI informed the first group of Belgian HSBC clients that they were in possession of evidence of fraud against them, but it refused to provide any further information to the suspects. At that point, a wrestling match began between the BBI and the suspects over how much evidentiary information would be released to the bank clients.
De Tijd, a Belgian newspaper, reported that the BBI asked all of the Belgian suspects to provide the account numbers of all foreign accounts they have held over the past seven years. With that request, the BBI increased its chances of getting more financial and banking information on the suspects than they already had. On the other side of the dispute, the suspects are citing a 1994 law that requires the BBI to share with them the complete files of evidence they are using in their prosecution because failure to do so impedes the suspects’ ability to defend themselves properly. In response, the BBI cited exceptions in the same law that allow it to withhold information.
The first hearing on the dispute took place in the Belgian Council of State in early September, after which De Tijd reported that the council’s general auditor did not appear to favor the BBI argument. An official ruling is expected in two months.
Questions of Ethnic Bias
During the legal maneuverings in the case, an information “leak” gave a De Tijd journalist access to the BBI files. In a September 3, 2011, article, De Tijd identified a half dozen suspects by name and described them as “mostly members of the Jewish community, with a handful of Indian diamantaires.” Among them, prominent Jewish members of the Antwerp diamond industry were profiled in greater detail. The local community complained that the newspaper’s identification of the suspects as Jewish reflected an anti-Jewish bias, especially considering that the 79,000 names in the worldwide HSBC case represent a wide diversity of nationalities, cultures, religions and backgrounds.
Another Belgian newspaper offered a public apology for publishing a similar list in which individuals were identified as Jewish. Luc Van Der Kelen, chief editor of Het Laatste Nieuws/De Nieuwe Gazet, wrote that “every stigmatization of any community should be suppressed.” Hans Deridder, deputy editor in chief, added “publishing the labels ‘Jew’ or ‘Jewish’ in justice matters” — as the newspaper had done — “is twice finger-pointing and is unacceptable… I’ve immediately taken all necessary steps to prevent any such situation in the future.”
The Marketplace
Polished:
- The diamond community was awaiting the results of the Hong
Kong show at press time. It was expected that industry members who have been
speculating too much and who are having liquidity problems would start selling
in Hong Kong.
- Globally, prices have softened slightly in some categories
— losing 3 percent to 5 percent — but the VS-SI goods are holding firm since
the rough to manufacture them was very expensive. Manufacturers bought rough
too high and are finding it difficult to pass those prices on to the retail market.
- The lowering of the Rapaport list prices in August, in
conjunction with the tensions in the financial and national debt markets, has
caused buyers to be more cautious, despite the existence of real demand.
- Since the U.S. market is no longer the dominant market — a
position that’s being taken over by the Asian countries — it is seeing more
shortages of goods.
- Expectations are that by the end of 2011, barring any major financial catastrophes, prices will recover their recent losses.
Rough:
- Rough prices have declined.
- The premiums on boxes have vaporized and some boxes,
mainly Indian goods, are being sold at a loss, which is reportedly the case for
Diamond Trading Company (DTC) boxes. Russian boxes are reported to be sold at
cost or at a 3 precent to 5 percent loss.
- The industry continues to fear that the high level of speculation will cause more dealers to sell at a loss because they need the cash.



