Market Tries to Find Footing

RAPAPORT… 
Traditionally, this time of the year is one of the busiest periods for the diamond trade because of the Hong Kong Jewellery & Gem Fair, the largest and one of the most important and popular annual shows for the industry. Activity and sales at the show are considered important indicators of what business will be like in the months leading up to the Christmas season, as well as the relative strengths and weaknesses of individual markets within the global marketplace.

Planning and preparations begin in mid-August and build up momentum to the show itself, which this year was held from September 19 to 25. As usual, the show was split between AsiaWorld-Expo (AWE) at the Hong Kong International Airport and the Hong Kong Convention & Exhibition Centre (HKCEC) in the city.

Double Whammy

However, this year, in the critical weeks leading up to the Hong Kong show, the diamond trade was hit by a double whammy. First, the worldwide reaction to the threatened American debt default and the subsequent downgrading of the U.S. credit rating sent equity markets across the globe into a tailspin.

Secondly, the Rapaport list featured the dreaded “italics” — indicating price drops — in a small section of the list, which raised the concern of traders that a further lowering of the prices might be forthcoming. In response, buyers put on the brakes and stopped buying. Only small sales to meet immediate demands were concluded.

In the weeks following the appearance of the italicized declines on the list, prices did soften considerably after some Indian diamond dealers started to sell into the market. But even this sales push did not help much to encourage sales, as buyers adopted a wait-and-see attitude in anticipation of future changes in the Rapaport list.

A later price drop in Rapaport’s fancy shape list only aggravated the situation as buyers took that as a signal that a change in the rounds list was imminent. The prices of diamonds normally find their own levels as buyers and sellers find common ground, but any movement of the Rapaport list has a huge impact on the confidence of the buyers.

Nobody likes to buy a diamond only to find that it is worth less the following Friday. While price declines undermine confidence, it should also be noted that the continuous escalation of prices seen in recent months boosted business as buyers moved to conclude purchases before any changes occurred when the list was published the next Friday. These increases helped carry the normally tepid June jewelry show to new highs and buyers easily accepted the increases.

Premiums and Discounts

While buyers have not been happy with the big premiums and small discounts that have prevailed recently, sellers attributed them to the high cost of the diamond rough. Now, the situation is quite different as rough prices have tumbled and all the premiums that existed previously have vanished. In fact, dealers are now coming, cap in hand, trying to sell rough. Traders and manufacturers are prepared to adjust their prices and even take a loss on expensive inventory if they can replace it with the deflated rough.

Demand is still in place, especially in the Far Eastern regions, with the exception of Japan, which is still recovering from the natural disasters it faced early in 2011. At a price, diamonds can still be sold, but in this volatile economic environment, there is a great deal of confusion as to what is a safe investment. Even gold, which soared over $1,900 an ounce, has retreated by $200.

Although everyone accepts some fluctuation in the value of their investments, they want reassurance that their holdings will retain value in comparison to other investment instruments. The diamond industry clearly remembers 2008, when diamond prices headed south and discounts fell to 50 percent and more — and it doesn’t want to see that happen again.

Banking Pressure

Banks are under pressure from their comptrollers to increase their reserves to weather the turmoil brewing in the European countries. The banks, in turn, tighten the screws on their clients by cutting their credit lines and accelerating loan repayments. That scenario has caused some weakness in the Indian diamond market, which explains the lower prices for diamonds sold in Hong Kong in recent weeks.  

There is, however, a ray of hope. Prices for large goods have softened slightly but the demand remains strong as a shortage of these sizes still exists. Highly desirable goods in better colors in VS and SI continue to sell well.

Ahead of the industry is the October Golden Week in Mainland China and the Christmas season. Even if there is a decrease in demand as compared to the double-digit increases seen over the past two years, the Hong Kong and China markets are still big and should perform better than Europe or the U.S.


The Marketplace

  • Large stones over 5 carats, especially 10 carats and larger, find interested buyers.

  • Goods from 3 carats down to 1 carat, in high colors in VS-SI and in low colors from VVS2 to SI, are still moving.

  • Prices for small Indian setting sizes have retreated, but the high price of gold and platinum means that the prices for finished jewelry are meeting stiff resistance from buyers. The ultimate consumers for low- and medium-price jewelry will be more hesitant to buy in the rest of 2011, because concerns about unemployment and inflation, as well as economic uncertainties, bear heavily on this buying sector.

More From Rapaport Magazine

Featured