Economic Indicators
The year so far has provided a lot of economic ups and downs for independent jewelers. “The first six months of 2011, we were rocking and rolling, but the past few months, it’s quieted down,” said H Bredemeier, owner of H & H Jewels in Coconut Grove, Florida. He attributed some of the slowdown to the usual summertime drop-off, but also blamed the media’s coverage of the recession for scaring away customers.
It’s also been a changeable year in Pennsylvania. “The economy didn’t adversely affect our business the first six months of 2011, but in the last quarter, traffic has been slow,” said Abraham Frost, president of Frost & Co. Diamonds in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. “The gift business has really taken a big hit. We’re not in an era right now of ‘wants.’ We’re more in an era of ‘needs,’ and it doesn’t feel right to buy now unless it adds to your basic needs. But we’re in the business of excess, and there are people not even buying carpet for their house, let alone a diamond ring.”
Out West, the economy is similarly challenging, though customers have been less concerned with the news. “I think the public as a whole is pretty tired of the press out there, and has just decided to move on,” said Curtis Bennett, vice president of retail operations at O.C. Tanner, with two stores in Utah. “I went into August thinking it would be typical, and then there was a downtick in the stock market, so I trimmed back our outstanding orders. Then August was double what we’d projected.”
Changing market conditions were also a factor in the Midwest. “2010 was an up year for us,” said Mike Lordo, president of Lordo’s Diamonds in Ladue, Missouri. “Then the first quarter of 2011 was 30 percent down, year on year. So we were on target with 2009, which was not where we wanted to be. Then we overcame that, and now we’re just about caught up.”
Stores also have found that even when customers come in, sales are getting smaller. “The average ticket price is a little smaller than in 2010, and consumer expectations are going down a little bit,” said Lance Buttars, owner of Molinelli’s Jewelers in Pocatello, Idaho. “They’re either compromising a little on size or on quality to meet their budgets. But the pie here is a little smaller, too. A lot of chain stores have closed in the past year. We’re celebrating 108 years this year, and it’s good to be the oldest guy on the block.”
Stock Prices
With all the market changes, retailers have had a hard time gauging inventory levels. “Our biggest challenge is trying to figure out which way the economy is going to go,” said Lordo. “I’m not scared, but we’re cautious. I think the biggest obstacle we’ve run into is trying to buy right.”
Bennett agreed. “In 2008, we ordered big and took all those orders, and then our sales were down and we were left with a lot of jewelry,” he said. “So we’ve been trying to negotiate our inventory, and also make sure we don’t have a tired look. That’s been our biggest challenge.”
Looking Ahead
In Florida, Bredemeier was hoping for a positive end to the year. “I’m expecting a good holiday,” he said. “We’re selling more large-ticket items, and I think the clients in the upper echelon are still spending, and will keep spending. The average guy is hurting, though, and I think there are a lot of people who are still feeling the recession.”
If the year stabilizes, most jewelers expect Christmas to be bright. “I think holiday 2011 will be better than holiday 2010,” said Buttars. “Last year was better than the year before for us. We’ve had double-digit increases since 2005.”
For many retailers, including Lordo, just a little calm would be a nice way to end the year. “I’m not looking for a great Christmas, but I’m not looking for a bad Christmas,” he said. “If this Christmas is as good as it was last year, which was decent, I’ll be happy.”
The Marketplace
- Round sells best, as always. Cushion sales are increasing,
and princess sales are slowing.
- 1.25-carat and 1.50-carat stones are moving quickly.
- SI1 and SI2 are tied for most popular clarity, though
higher-end customers go for VS2.
- H-I is the top-selling color range.
- Due to increasing gold prices, platinum is beginning to
catch up to 14-karat gold as a choice for settings, though 14-karat and
18-karat gold still reign.
- The average price for an engagement ring, including stone and setting, is $5,680.



